Through Justice Came Mercy

My mother, the local school teacher, answered the authoritative knock on the door of her country home.

The policeman standing respectfully before her served a large rural area, in and around Winfield, Alberta.  He knew a great deal about most of the inhabitants within his jurisdiction,  “Mrs. D., how are you today?  May I speak with you in private?  I have a question to ask you.”

Mother knew exactly what prompted the Constable’s visit that day in the early 1940s.

Over the previous years, the Public Health Nurse and my mother, had worked in concert when various family issues surfaced and affected the children.  During mother’s experience in schools, she agonized over the effects of dire poverty.  Evidence popped up in classrooms as reliably as gopher’s heads in the prairie stubble.  The Public Health Nurse provided the only safe place for my mother to vent her concerns and frustrations.  She bemoaned the endless and life-threatening pregnancies of women who laboured in partnership with their husbands to keep farms afloat and somewhat productive.  Mother greeted hungry, cold and silent children who not only tended chores morning and night, but who also readily placed them above an education.

“Nurse Fergusson*,” my mom protested, “not only do these women not need any more mouths to feed, they do not want any more children!  They let me know in all sorts of different ways whenever I speak to them about their children.  What can be done?”

Canadian Nurse in the 1940s

Nurse Fergusson said, “Besides their feeble attempts at the rhythm method or quick withdrawal, you mean?  Or self induced abortion?”

“What about that birth-control program for low-income women that started in Ontario a few years ago? I read that a group organized themselves and can now legally obtain contraceptives by mail order.  They can even get referrals to physicians who can now prescribe some sort of diaphragms for contraception.  Can we do that here?”  Mom asked.

“Maybe they can do that in Ontario.” the nurse said.  In the early 1940s, although Ontario was another Canadian province, it was distant from Western Canada in more ways than in miles.  It may as well have been another country when considering impact of sensitive issues or political advancements.

“I saw an advertisement in an American magazine about French Safes.  Could we get a supply of those and could you distribute them?” Mom asked.

“If we could get a supply of French Safes from anywhere, I could not be the one to hand them out, Dorothy.  If the authorities found out, I would be the first one they’d suspect.”

“Would they suspect me?” Mom asked.

“I’m sure they’d think of you because you are an educated woman.  But at least you can elude them by standing firm on the fact that the School District needs children to justify its existence,” she laughed.

“Let’s order them from the States.  I’ll distribute them,” Mom said.

The order was sent and the illicit packages began arriving.

Mother picked up her parcels on a regular basis with the postmistress contorting her meager streak of diplomacy in hopes of identifying the contents.

This visit from the local constabulary was not a surprise to my mother.

“Come on in, Constable Newman*.  We have privacy.  None of the children are home.  Is there a problem?”

“Well, Mrs. D., there’s concern over illegal contraband having found its way into the countryside.  You have so much contact with so many families, I thought you may be able to help me find out who’s bringing it in,” he said.

“Illegal contraband?  Oh dear.  That sounds serious.  What type of contraband?” Mom asked.

“It’s a form of birth control.  A type of contraceptive,”  the policeman’s face flared red.

“Oh my goodness.  How on earth did you discover this, Constable?”

“Some of the men have been complaining.  It sort of leaked out.”  Again, his face flushed when he realized what he had said.

“Well, you know, Constable, none of the men would ever dream of talking to me about that sort of thing.  I’ve heard nothing from them at all.  But if I do hear anything, I will let you know.”

“Thank you, Mrs. D.  I knew I could count on your help.”  He reached for the door handle and opened the door to leave.  He paused.  “You know, if you do have the opportunity to talk to people about this, let them know there can be dire consequences.”

“Oh my goodness.  Like what?”

“A jail sentence,” he said and turned to walk to the police car.

“I’ll be sure to pass that information along.”  Mom said as she made a mental note to bring the postmistress into the office of the Public Heath Nurse at the next opportunity.

Years later, when Mother was telling me this story, I asked her about the outcome.

“The Constable knew it was me.  But I trusted the loyalty of my contacts and knew the policeman had no proof.  In those days, the “School Marm” carried a bit of power.  I used it that day.  If he’d asked to search my house, he would have found nothing, but I knew that he would not undertake such an aggressive act on the only School Teacher for miles around.   If I was unhappy or put in jail, he’d have the whole countryside down his throat.”

I asked, “What about the postmistress?”

“We lured her into the Health Office.  I accused her of reporting me to the police.  She denied that, of course.  Whether she did or didn’t – it was immaterial.  She made the mistake of stating outright, ‘I didn’t tell Constable Newman about the French Safes!’   Nurse Fergusson and I immediately pointed out that she was an accomplice.  It was our word against hers – we both heard that she knew what was contained in the parcels.  We explained that we’d simply tell the truth that she’d handed all those parcels over to us, knowing what was in them.   It spelled complicity.”


“You know, darling, there are times when one has to juggle justice to exercise mercy.”

(*Not the real names.)

The Guides response will follow this post.





16 thoughts on “Through Justice Came Mercy

  1. Hi Amy .. you certainly have some lovely stories to tell .. there must have been so much of that – we had petrol stashed away by my father .. and the local bobby lived down the lane and across the road – I’m sure he knew .. but we were law abiding & just doing our best to exist and to help others .. extra veg from the garden etc & the extra meat from the pigs we kept .. et al … common sense prevailed! Thanks – Amy a ‘fun’ tale .. Hilary

    • There was a bit more flexibility for those who had to maintain the law back then, methinks, Hilary. I hope some of my employees saw that in some of my decisions when trying to work with silly policies. Rules were built for one reason and often impacted innocents.

      • Hi Amy .. that’s for sure! I bend/break rules .. as long as they do no harm & things happen quicker .. being stuck between two rails only going in one direction is pretty dull making! My soul likes to get out and about! If those that made the rules actually did them mind bendingly for a few months – they’d realise the error of their ways I hope! But they’re here to stay for a while ..

        • One time I had to decide between following the law to the letter and acting from the heart. Fortunately I ran into my Rector and asked his opinion. After listening, he quietly said, “Do what the angels would do.” I was happy with my decision…still am today.

  2. Hi Amy .. sensible rector! and to know that you’re happy with that still .. is good news! I’ve given up the unequal trouble of walking to Mum’s .. I’m sure the angels will be looking after her .. cheers Hilary

  3. Amy, you are a bad bad girl!! Ha ha.. And why did the officer’s face flush again 😉 The postmistress looks like she is a person of far less intelligence than your mother!
    They caught one of my friends for speeding and the judge withheld the fine on him in spite of his appeal, and he (the judge) pointed out that he blurted to the police officer who stopped him, “Sorry!”.. He had just admitted to his mistake! Duh-uh 🙂

    • But Rachana…you are the only one who mentioned the flush…so who’s bad? That was a miserably tough judge. I’ve apologized profusely to policemen and generally ended up with warnings. They are probably scared I’ll burst into tears. Men have such a hard time with that! 🙂

Love to "hear" from you...please leave a comment. If you wish to Subscribe, go to the "Home" tab and look to the right.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s